Yes, and it;s one reason why I could understand this action. I thought Sam wasn't actually Sam during the soulless story line. I thought he was an impostor so when Dean beat him up I was like - take that impostor! Turns out it was Sam and in hindsight it made me sad that Dean could be so vicious to his brother. But it's also very Dean, so it was believable.
Wiping Lisa and Ben's memories doesn't make any sense at all, and I chalk that up to bad writing.
It makes NO sense. What about her neighbours? friends? How screwed up would she be if everyone kept asking about Dean and she's like "who?". She's probably in an insane asylum (and wow, that would make for an interesting storyline in the future).
And because of that, I don't see a problem with Dean saying that "he'd do it again."
Haha, well, we know this is the "agree to disagree" point. I hate Dean for saying that - I think even more than the act itself. I have no problem with him saying he's try and save Sam again - but he'd try and do it in a way that Sam didn't have to suffer so much. If Dean thinks he could watch needles being pushed into Sam's brain again then…argh….Dean, he's your brother! I accept that he'll always try to save Sam (and now that Sam would save Dean), but I STILL want them to figure out that there are certain lines not worth crossing (and curious that Dean has already mentioned that in regards to Lester. My hope might be realised this season…;D)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2014-11-09 12:32 pm (UTC)Dean doesn't know that Sam didn't have a soul.
Yes, and it;s one reason why I could understand this action. I thought Sam wasn't actually Sam during the soulless story line. I thought he was an impostor so when Dean beat him up I was like - take that impostor! Turns out it was Sam and in hindsight it made me sad that Dean could be so vicious to his brother. But it's also very Dean, so it was believable.
Wiping Lisa and Ben's memories doesn't make any sense at all, and I chalk that up to bad writing.
It makes NO sense. What about her neighbours? friends? How screwed up would she be if everyone kept asking about Dean and she's like "who?". She's probably in an insane asylum (and wow, that would make for an interesting storyline in the future).
And because of that, I don't see a problem with Dean saying that "he'd do it again."
Haha, well, we know this is the "agree to disagree" point. I hate Dean for saying that - I think even more than the act itself. I have no problem with him saying he's try and save Sam again - but he'd try and do it in a way that Sam didn't have to suffer so much. If Dean thinks he could watch needles being pushed into Sam's brain again then…argh….Dean, he's your brother! I accept that he'll always try to save Sam (and now that Sam would save Dean), but I STILL want them to figure out that there are certain lines not worth crossing (and curious that Dean has already mentioned that in regards to Lester. My hope might be realised this season…;D)