ash48: (Discussion / no weapons discharge)
[personal profile] ash48
Note: There are spoilers in the interview. Under the cut are spoilers for the Mark's affect on Dean only - and minor speculation.

Jensen's kindly given an interview to The Winchester Brothers on Winchester Radio recently (I suggest you avoid the comments in the above link if you want to avoid some nastiness. I accidentally saw some and decided to respond. I KNOW I shouldn't have done but dammit I was steaming). I actually read a transcript of the interview (and I've just seen that [livejournal.com profile] stir_of_echoes has created one also <3) rather than listen to it. I started to listen but found it a little…er…messy (which might have been because of nerves maybe).



I think [livejournal.com profile] missyjack said it best when she called Jensen the ultimate Dean!girl. :) And so he should be. Listening to him talk about Dean is wonderful and insightful. I love how supportive he is of the character and it has given me some insights to how he goes about playing him. I particularly love how he includes his experiences in Purgatory as something that drives Dean. We never see that (unfortunately!), but it's wonderful that Jensen's using it for inspiration.

It's also interesting to hear his take on Sam. Some of it I found hard to accept and I didn't agree with quite a bit of it, but I did find it interesting. I know that Jensen probably doesn't spent a lot of time analysing Sam's character (if at all), so it's not surprising that his comments are based on Dean's experience of Sam and not how he sees Sam fitting into the overall picture. Which makes sense because as an actor you are totally focused on your own character (I'm hoping Jared will do a similar interview because I'd love to hear his insights into Sam).

I wasn't totally thrilled by the pitch of some of the questions (in fact, it was a little disappointing that the interviewers weren't more objective and even handed with the questions) but there were some great questions that allowed Jensen to really talk about his character.

Some interesting comments he made:

Obviously, Dean is willing to go all-in and keep the family together, and keep the brothers moving down the road and it seems that more and more, Sam is willing to cash out and he’s not willing to put his life on the line the way that Dean is.

Not going to deny that this comment really took me aback. I have no idea what "cash out" means but if this is the Sam we are going to be seeing in the future it might well be the final straw for me. I'm not quite sure what Jensen's take on 8.23 was but Sam was completely ready to put his life on the line for the greater good. And er….end S5? Though I will accept that Jensen might be channeling Dean and thinks that Sam won't lay his life on the line for Dean. Which is crazy of course, but it's something Dean would absolutely be feeling (though if Show decides that actually Sam WON'T lay his life on the line for Dean then it's not the show I originally started watching so it'll be all over red rover for me).


That’s a tough pill for Dean to swallow, and I think the only way he’s dealing with it is by not dealing with it.

That's a really interesting observation and I think that's definitely true. I love that he mentioned this because I've wondered if Dean not acknowledging what Sam has suffered is part of him just not wanting to deal. We've seen Dean shut down more and more I think.


The mark of Cain has given him a simplicity in his thoughts that’s allowing him to ignore the complexity of their relationship right now and focus on the prize, which is Abbadon at this point

Fair call..but…um….Abbadon is the prize? I thought Gadreel was on the top of Dean's list? Not sure exactly how Addadon became top priority. Maybe it's because it's what Crowley wants? I'm trying to remember why Addadon is such a thorn in Dean's side - considering she hasn't really featured much this season (or last for that matter). Curious.


So, I think the line between black and white is becoming almost dangerously clear, the grey areas are becoming less and less as far as Dean is concerned.

Awesome! The Mark is going to be really interesting for Dean. Seeing a cold (almost soulless) Dean is going to give Jensen some great stuff to work with and will be great to watch.


Yeah, for a long time there were a lot of different storylines going on, mostly revolving around Sam, and what the story was doing to Sam although a lot of it, it could be said was being seen through Dean’s perspective, the story was always, kind of about Sam and what was going on internally with him

Pretty much what we all know and have said for a while. Though not sure how "what was going on internally with him" means as we don't get a lot on what's going on with him internally. I mean, we get the angst but we don't get to see the result of all the crap that happens to him. But I get it - from Dean's perspective stuff is ALWAYS happening to Sam (and my god it really is!) and I kinda get the sense that Jensen is happy for the "stuff" is now going to be happening to him.

Which I'm pretty darn excited by too. He also talks about the roles reversing - which makes me wonder if we'll get to watch Dean's story through Sam's eyes now? I think that would be pretty cool if handled right.


Yeah, Sam’s a real selfish asshole is what it boils down to (laughs)

It is true, Sam seems to be a little preoccupied and maybe it’s a little brother thing. Maybe he’s

“You’re my big brother you can figure it out yourself.”

But that’s a contrast to the way Dean thinks as in, “I’m the big brother and I have to protect my little brother from harm.” That’s kind of been his creed for as long as he can remember so I think that they both kind of come at it from different angles. Sam is more willing to allow for things to happen as they happen and it’s a Sam-centric world in his mind, and I think it always has been and I think it’s been a Sam-centric show for a long time


Yeah. I probably should just let this go. I know Jensen said some of this in jest but if even Jensen thinks Sam's an asshole what the hell hope do any of us have that think he's not. *sigh* And Sam is Sam-centric? Yeah, saving the world was all about Sam. Trying to trade himself for Dean in hell was clearly all about Sam. Sam continuing to hunt, save people, listen and help people is only because Sam thinks about himself. Clearly. (I know I am coming across as some sort of bitter Sam!girl, but I seriously must be watching a different show if, after everything, Sam is still considered selfish). I am aware that Jensen is talking about the characters and it makes sense that that is what Dean would be thinking - but even then Dean KNOWS Sam is not selfish - he's seen first hand the things Sam has been willing to do for others. I suppose it's fair that Jensen might think that though - considering a lot of fandom thinks the same.

What does come across clearly is Jensen wanting something more for his character. And I don't blame him. When we look back and think about everything that has happened to Sam it's pretty epic. Jared has been able to play all sorts of characters - many different versions of Sam. Jensen hasn't really had that opportunity, so I think Jensen has a right to be feeling pretty over Jared getting all the cool stuff. Jensen plays "dark" very well (end!verse Dean is still one of my fav Deans) and I think the Mark is going to give him some great material to work with. Oooh, we still might get to see 2014!Dean emerge. That would be wicked if they somehow gave us that future version of Dean - what a cool tie in.


Whether he protects him because of the fear of loneliness, whatever the reason is, I don’t think Dean sits in his bed and psychoanalyses himself all that much.

Definitely. And interestingly it's coming across exactly like that. WE do! But Dean doesn't. Even non-Mark Dean wouldn't contemplate his motivations too much. He just is.


Winchester Radio: To that end, are there any decisions that Dean has made over the years that you could revisit and possibly alter in some way?

What would be the issue if you were to do so?

Jensen: Not invite Gadreel into Sam. That would be number one on the list.


*phew* I'm glad we're on the same page about that. And he, like me, understands that what Dean did is all part of the story telling. This isn't Jensen saying he didn't what that for Dean, but rather knowing that Dean would want do-over on that one decision.


I have to say this interview hasn't given me a lot of hope for the storyline exploring Sam being possessed against his will (not that Jensen would know or possibly worry about). It's just not on their radar. I probably have to accept that if I want to continue to enjoy the season (and series actually). I just have to accept that, much like last season, the reasons for why Sam is behaving in a certain way is not an issue - just that what he's doing is enough to create a reaction from Dean. And now that the story is moving to the Mark (and Dean changing because of it), there will be even less focus on Dean feeling/learning/growing from anything he's done. In fact, Sam's attitude is likely to be driving him toward that darkness. Sam will just have to move on (*fandom cheers*) and forget that the first part of the season even happened for him. I could be wrong and they may well integrate Sam's past experiences into his story arc, but I can't see it. Though I suspect we'll be watching Sam fight for his brother - which will be cool too. At this point it's the only thing I can imagine happening that will calm down all the hate.

It's so wonderful that Jensen gave up his time to give this interview. It's a shame that it will (already has) created even more of the Sam v Dean crap. I ranted on tumblr about all that so I won't repeat it here. Needless to say I am totally over it and I think I might be joining fellow fans and remaining off fandom sites until the storyline allows people to actually behave civilly.

That said, I am more than happy to discuss the interview as long there's no nastiness - for either Sam, Dean or Jensen.

Date: 2014-03-12 11:58 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] reggie11.livejournal.com
Oh wow. That was kind of. Um...

If the way Jensen has portrayed the storyline going is the way it's going down, I'm not sure it will hold my interest through season ten. If they really do make this about Dean being the selfless hero and Sam being ungrateful and selfish, I'm going to be seriously disappointed.

It'll be interesting if Sam has to fight for his brother if Dean goes darkside but if it's all just to make Dean the ultimate hero and Sam the bad guy then it will ruin it for me. I've never seen one brother as better than the other and I've never seen Sam as the bad guy, just a guy that made some bad choices through extenuating circumstances. I think Dean has made some pretty bad choices too. I'm kind of fed up with them demonizing (no pun intended) Sam.

I was hopeful that the current storyline would have been a chance for Dean to grow and learn like Sam has and have the brothers build a whole new level to their relationship but this interview really makes it sound like all of it will be swept under the rug again and frankly, that would be tiresome. If things just keep going in circles like 'save my brother at any cost' followed by 'everything backfires because of it', rinse and repeat, then the show won't hold my interest anymore. Too much repetitiveness just gets boring.

It was great Jensen gave his time for this but the interview made me cringe.

Date: 2014-03-12 12:37 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ash48.livejournal.com
If they really do make this about Dean being the selfless hero and Sam being ungrateful and selfish, I'm going to be seriously disappointed.

Personally I will be weeping into my pillow, but I HAVE to believe that Carver preparing to explore both character arcs. It feels like there's been this huge set up to explore some really deep issues for both of them but if this has all been about making one brother "right" over the other then it will all be for nothing. Last season I don't think either brother was treated particularly nicely (I wonder if Carver actually likes these characters?) and it looks like he's treating them much the same way this season.

I can only hope he's got a cunning (and wonderful) plan that sees both brothers being treated fairly.

It was great Jensen gave his time for this but the interview made me cringe.

I have to admit my heart sank at a few moments. There was some great stuff there too but all I was thinking was how much this will stir up even more Sam hate. And it has. :( (and I believe Jensen has copped some too. *sigh*)

Date: 2014-03-12 02:19 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] reggie11.livejournal.com
I've purposely avoided looking at any of the comments associated with it because I know it will get my hackles up. I can't really understand how people can have such a hate on for one of the two main characters, usually Sam. There are things both of them have done that I've really disliked but I've never hated either character, if I did, I don't hink I could watch the show.

I've been thinking for quite a while that Carver doesn't seem to like the characters he writes for, especially Sam. There are only a few episodes he's written where he doesn't seem to be purposely trying to make Sam out to be a bad guy. He's done one or two that are very sympathetic to Sam but the rest are all heavily sympathetic to Dean. For a show that's supposedly based on a tight brotherly bond and a great familial bond to each other it doesn't really add up.

You've remained more optimistic than me I'm afraid. I was very optimistic about this story arc in the beginning, I found it really exciting because it has so much potential but the last few episodes have kind of killed that optimism for me. The little speech Linda Tran made seemed to cement that they are trying to push the agenda that Dean is right doing absolutely anything if his motive is to keep them together as family, and Kevin telling them basically to get over it because it's stupid. I'm just not sure I want to keep watching a show that keeps rehashing the characters making the same mistakes over and over. It's not like I didn't want Dean to save Sam - of course I did - and it's not like I don't want them to get past it and be close again, I just want them to write Dean really finally understanding why Sam is so hurt and angry and acknowledging that he has every right to be, apologise properly and then have them move forward.

Date: 2014-03-12 08:26 pm (UTC)
stormcloude: peace (Default)
From: [personal profile] stormcloude
One of the things I loved about Kripke was how much the show was a love letter when he was in charge-- a love letter to family, to rock music, to Americana and the open road and folklore.

I don't think that Carver loves anything. I kind of wonder if he even HAS siblings and if he does what his relationship is like with them, because family is definitely taking a beating under his reign.

Date: 2014-03-12 11:37 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] reggie11.livejournal.com
Hmmm, that made me think. It may just be the opposite. I lost my brother to a very aggressive cancer a few years ago and it was the most devastating thing you could possibly imagine. We all expected him to be able to go through treatment that would give him a chance and when the doctor told us he only had days and chemo couldn't possibly save him it was like our world stopped. We were told it may extend his life by a couple of weeks but it would also be even more excruciating for him. Even though we all wanted more time together, my brother made the only choice he could, no chemo. At first his wife tried to talk him into it so she could have him longer so he told me his wishes were to spend a day saying all of his goodbyes and then he wanted oblivion and to go quickly so he put me in charge of the medical decisions knowing I would follow them to the letter. When he told me he was ready I had the doctors keep up pain relief only and had him completely sedated until he passed a few days later. There were relatives who thought the decision was wrong and that he should have had the chemo so THEY could have had more time with him even though he would have suffered even more horrifically. My point is, maybe Carver has lost someone who was kind of made to fight and maybe by some miracle they were saved and this is justification, or maybe he's one of those people who has lost someone to suicide and feels he would have fought to his last breath to save them if he'd only had a chance. It could be just a totally fictional story that sprung up and I'm just projecting what has been looping through my mind since this arc began because I relate way too closely and heavily on Sam's side - if you really love someone you honour their choices no matter how painful it is to yourself and if it's the right thing to do, you let go.

I'm happy Dean saved Sam because otherwise there'd be no Sam in the show, I just want them to have Dean acknowledge that he knows he ripped away Sam's choices and that he now understands Sam's side and promise to save Sam in every human way possible but that he'll never cross that kind of line again and then have them kiss and make up ;)

Date: 2014-03-13 09:46 am (UTC)
stormcloude: peace (Default)
From: [personal profile] stormcloude
I'm sorry for your loss. It sounds like it was a tough time.

And I agree with you about Sam and Dean. ;)

Date: 2014-03-13 11:43 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ash48.livejournal.com
I'm so sorry to hear about your loss. What a horrible thing to go through.

It's worthy comparison and it's much the same way I view Dean's decision. He wanted more time with Sam so made the choice for him - even when he knew it wouldn't be something he'd want.

It would be amazing if they decided to explore this dilemma - I fear they won't but it's such a good opportunity to do so.


*hugs*

Profile

ash48: (Default)
ash48

January 2020

S M T W T F S
    1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jan. 20th, 2026 11:07 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios